Class
action reform likely?
A
law that could mean as much to the insurance industry as a drop-off in natural
disasters is close to becoming a reality. The Class Action Fairness Act
could become law early in 2004. The measure which passed in the House last
year but stalled in the Senate has been the scene of a bitter battleground
with insurers, consumer groups, attorneys and businesses getting into the
fray.
The
CAFA would take most class-action suits out of state courts and put them
in the federal system, essentially limiting insurers' exposure on big
judgments. Obstacles to passage have largely disappeared after Republicans
made significant concessions to Democrats in order to get bipartisan support
for the measure in the Senate. The House easily passed the bill last summer
by a vote of 253 to 170.
The
CAFA would put a stop to venue shopping by attorneys who want to hold
trials in jurisdictions historically sympathetic to injured parties. The
measure would move class actions lawsuits that seek more than $5 million
and affect plaintiffs in multiple states from state courts to the federal
judiciary.
The
bill would also prohibit settlements in which class members actually lose
money after paying attorneys' fees.
Catastrophe
modeling now part of doing business
15
years ago when catastrophe modeling tools were first developed, only a
handful of insurers used them as benchmarks for forecasting maximum losses.
That was before the first multi-billion dollar catastrophic loss. Today
catastrophic modelers are vital tools for the industry to forecast casualty
exposures and help companies make business decisions.
The
terrorist attacks have ushered in a new wave of modeling tools though
they are not used as commonly as those models that focus on natural catastrophes.
When
the models were first introduced in the 1980s, they focused on earthquakes
and hurricanes in a geographic area. Now they incorporate winter storms,
tornadoes, floods, fires and other perils as well as made-made catastrophes.
A large commercial insurance or reinsurance company with worldwide operations
and multiple perils can now have a handle on its aggregate risk around
the globe.
Another
factor leading to the growth of modeling is the quality of data collected
by insurers. With the tidalwave of data available, insurers can use models
to predict exposures by zip codes and make price and underwriting decisions
on individual accounts.
Industry
observers say the new terrorism models are less well accepted for a good
reason: it's much harder to build a model based on the likely activities
of irrational humans than it is to predict occurrences of nature.
Insurers
warned to avoid price war
Frank
J. Coyne Insurers warned to avoid price war Industry observers believe
that the hard market for insurance may be coming to an end and they caution
insurers not to "sow the seeds of their own destruction" by engaging in
a competitive price war to increase business. That was the phrase used
by the Insurance Services Office CEO Frank Coyne in a conference address
late last year.
Rate
increases of the past two years strengthened the industry and improved
combined ratios. But for slower premium growth and the return of a soft
market worry Coyne. He pointed to the mid-1980s when the industry made
a strong recovery by setting premiums based on sound underwriting principles,
ushering a period of sustained profitability.
"With
each improvement in profitability, the property/casualty industry has
a history of reverting to hyper competition for market share…and slips
into a soft market," he cautioned.
ISO
data indicates that insurer insolvencies are increasing. Since 2000, an
average of 33 property/casualty insurers filed each year compared with
12 per year in the 1970s and 27 per year in the 1980s and 1990s.
FCRA
extended indefinitely
The
Fair Credit Reporting Act, which was set to expire in 2003, has been permanently
renewed by Congress on a 379-49 vote. The FCRA regulates The act regulates
the use of consumer credit information and affects every American consumer
and business.
The
National Association of Independent Insurers (NAII) praised the act as
a key tool in allowing the financial services and insurance industries
fight identity theft. An NAII spokesman called the FCRA the "beginning
of a process" for the insurance industry which is seeking standards for
credit scoring.
|